For over seventy-five years the Club has kept the same quiet promise: that a person walking in from a long day should be met with a fire of light, a well-made drink, and friendly hellos from staff and fellow patrons alike.
The new 4S Club is, in many ways, the old one — refinished. Solid walnut now warms the walls. Velvet banquettes, where folding tables once stood, invite the same long conversations. What’s new is the program. Our bar team has built a list that respects both the classics and the curious; a place to order a Manhattan with confidence, or to ask the bartender what they’ve been working on lately.
We remain a private members club — a place for members to gather over a drink, settle into the room, and feel part of the tradition. Visitors are welcome, by invitation... or curiosity.
Come in. Sit a while. Order something stirred.
4S Club History1914 – Today
The story so far.
From four fraternal organizartions and a rental hall on South High Street to its longtime home at the corner of Whittier & Blackberry Alley, the 4S has always been a place its members made their own.
1914
Four Saints, One Hall
Four Catholic fraternal organizations, each bearing the name of a saint — the St. Paul Beneficial Society, the Knights of St. John, the St. Francis Xavier Society, and St. Joseph’s Court of the Catholic Order of Foresters — join together to form the Auditorium Building Company and purchase Auditorium Hall at 581 S. High St.
1920s – 30s
A Hall for the Whole City
Led by a board elected from among the societies’ leaders, the Auditorium Building Company runs the hall and rents out its rooms. The societies book them for their meetings, luncheons, and gatherings — and groups from across Columbus do the same.
1940
The 4-S Club Is Born
Society members had been asking for club rooms of their own, and late in 1939 the board formed a committee to study how similar organizations ran theirs. In April 1940 the board resolved to set rooms aside as a club for society members; that December the company was awarded a club license for the 4-S Club and appointed Ferdinand J. "Ferd" Thomas as its first manager.
Ferdinand Thomas at Schiller Park in Columbus, Ohio.
1943
Open to Friends
The Club opens its doors wider, admitting social members on the recommendation of a member in good standing and the approval of the manager. Dues for social members are set at $1.00 a year.
1950s
In Full Swing
The 4-S is in full swing, with a monthly newsletter keeping members up to date on the happenings and events hosted by the Club, both inside its walls and beyond.
1962
A New Home on Whittier
Having sold Auditorium Hall, the Auditorium Building Company buys 281 E. Whittier St. as the Club’s new home. The grand opening is held on Saturday, September 22, 1962.
281 E. Whittier St.
1970s – 80s
The South End’s Living Room
Settled on Whittier Street, the 4-S becomes a second home for the neighborhood: Lenten fish fries and euchre nights, wedding receptions and wake luncheons, and a cold one after the game — as families raised in the societies bring along the next generation.
1990s – 2000s
Keeping the Lamps Lit
As the founding societies grow smaller, a loyal core of members keeps the doors open and the bar stocked, hosting the reunions, anniversaries, and holiday parties of families who have called the Club their own for generations.
2023
A New Set of Stewards
With society members using the Club less and less, the 4-S puts the Columbia Theater building at 281 E. Whittier St. up for sale. A group of longtime friends, members of the Catholic community all with family ties to the South End, purchase the Club — building and operations — from the Catholic societies, pledging a small portion of future profits back to the founding societies.
2026
The Next Chapter
Following extensive renovations and a brand-new commercial kitchen, the next iteration of the 4-S Club opens its doors. It may look quite different on the surface, but we intend to keep the spirit of the original 4-S alive for many years to come.
The room, refinished
GalleryInside the 4S
The Gallery.
A look inside the 4S.
Membership
A drink is better among friends.
The 4S is a private members’ club; guests are welcome by invitation. Membership opens the door any evening we’re open.